
Nearly 20 years, four books, and five movies after the world was first introduced to Katniss Everdeen, author Suzanne Collins and director Francis Lawrence have teamed up again to bring audiences the origin story of one of the franchise’s most beloved characters: Haymitch Abernathy.
In the original trilogy, Haymitch is played by Woody Harrelson, and both the character of Haymitch and the excellence with which Harrelson portrayed him have created very big shoes to fill for the franchise’s second prequel. Luckily for audiences, our new Haymitch, Joseph Zada, embodies not only Haymitch, but also Harrelson, in Sunrise on the Reaping.Â
Fans will be beyond happy with the younger version of many key players from the original trilogy. Each actor had their work cut out for them as they took on roles Hunger Games fans have known and loved (or loved to hate) for over a decade. Yet what seems like a daunting, impossible task was pulled off seamlessly.
One of the most fun characters to see more of is Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin), whom the audience gets to experience off-camera more than ever before, glimpsing into the man rather than the TV personality. Even characters with near-cameo parts like Wiress (Maya Hawke), Mags (Lili Taylor), and Beetee (Kelvin Harrison Jr.) are so well executed you’ll feel like Francis Lawrence took the original cast in a time machine to make this film.
Tied with Zada for the most impressive performance, though, is Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket. Typically, although a talented actress, Fanning finds it hard not to bring a bit of herself into every role she plays, reminding the viewer she’s a movie star and not really her character. Yet, in Sunrise on the Reaping, she manages to lose all Elle-Fanning-ness and embrace the character Elizabeth Banks originally made so complexly easy to love and hate.
Although a prequel starring characters audiences already know and love inevitably leans into fan service (and at times, Sunrise on the Reaping does this a little too much), it still offers plenty of newness to justify it. Perhaps the most obvious is the newly dubbed “people’s princess,” Maysilee Donner (McKenna Grace) one of the tributes from District 12. The courage and grace she brings to Maysilee show the audience a new way to fight the Capitol, as she is determined to keep her dignity.
The 50th Hunger Games brings with it a brand-new arena that jarringly feels straight out of Snow White, not a post-apocalyptic society. It’s so fake, in fact, that even many of the plants and animals aren’t real (I suspect part of this is on the Capitol’s part and part is due to real-life production design). Of course, the arenas are manufactured, but much of the film’s production design felt overproduced and obviously fake. Scenes in District 12 seem too clean, with some characters wearing clothes that are obviously machine-made when the audience is meant to believe all clothes are handmade from foraged materials. Even scenes in the Capitol boast cheap-looking, gold-foiled phones or couches you could find on Wayfair.
This isn’t a deep dive into why the book was better than the movie (another time, perhaps), but the film’s biggest failures aren’t true of the book. The most glaring is the lack of time dedicated to Haymitch and Maysilee’s relationship. The film wants us to believe Haymitch comes to think of Maysilee as the sister he always wanted, yet it never gives the audience time to see this relationship develop. Perhaps if Lawrence had been less inclined to spell out the politics of the games through cheesy cut scenes of Snow (here played by a Voldemort-esque Ralph Fiennes), he would have had time to include a few heartfelt scenes between our two main characters. In some ways, the film sacrifices the heartbreaking human stories at the center of the story in favor of reminding the viewer how corrupt the Capitol truly is. While politics are deeply ingrained in the morals and plot of The Hunger Games franchise, it’s the human stories that strike a chord and make viewers want to see change.
While more attention to the characters and relationships in the film would have made this one of the best of the franchise, Sunrise on the Reaping is still a fantastic, heart-breaking, edge-of-your-seat epic that must be seen on the big screen, especially for die-hard fans.

