in honor of opening day (for most of the major league), brent johnson gives a unique look at some of the best movies about america’s favorite past time.
To me, baseball is the most elegant, beautifully complex sport on the planet. Look at the way a double sails into the gap. The way a perfect pitch can paint the corner of the plate. The way a single inning — with a deluge of runs — can change the course of an evening.
Maybe that’s why baseball films are also the most poetic sports movies. Rocky is the ultimate underdog saga. Hoosiers has the greatest drama-drenched closing sequence. But more than any sport, baseball has produced the greatest amount of sports movie moments — because it has built-in nostalgia, built-in glory and built-in beauty.
So in honor of the start of this season of Major League Baseball — the Yankees opened with a loss against their hated Red Sox last night and the Mets begin by playing the Marlins at Shea … I mean, CitiField today — here are my favorite baseball flicks, presented in my own diamond-themed categories:
THE HALL-OF-FAME MANAGER
Description: The movie that’s like Connie Mack — an early 20th century coach who was a consummate professional and always a winner; in other words, the patriarch of all baseball movies
Example: The Natural
Barry Levinson’s 1982 rich, moving, sepia-toned adaptation of the classic novel about a washed-up player with a second chance at stardom is the consummate baseball film. It feeds of the game’s best traits: fairy-tale magic, childhood hopes, dashed dreams, underdog stories — and glorious, heroic moments. It also is a picture of the game at the height of its popularity: the early 20th century, when baseball was THE sporting event, just above horse-racing and boxing. Plus, I like that Levinson changed the book’s ending — if only for that wondrous Randy Newman score booming as the home-run ball smacks into the lights. That’s baseball at its best.
THE STARTING PITCHER
Description: The movie that’s like Greg Maddux — consistently strong, consistently entertaining and a valuable part of your rotation
Example: A League Of Their Own
Tom Hanks alone is worth a watch. Just marvel in the way he calls an umpire a “penis with a hat on.” Penny Marshall’s exploration of women’s baseball is more than just quotable — it’s funny, heartfelt, educational and endlessly enjoyable.
THE LEADOFF HITTER
Description: The movie that’s like Jose Reyes — a reliable hitter who can get on base, always making you perk up with wonder
Example: The Sandlot
It’s more than just a kid’s movie. But this tale of summer bonding and one unruly dog shows that baseball is a kid’s game — a sport that grips you when you’re young and stays with you. It instantly reminds you why baseball is the national pastime. The July 4th sequence is a surprisingly moving metaphor for that theory.
THE NO. 3 HITTER
Description: The movie that’s like George Brett — the best, most sturdy hitter on your team, always able to come through in the clutch
Example: Major League
Even more so than Bull Durham — the baseball comedy of all baseball comedies, but one that has never struck me as being genius — this playful poke at the Cleveland Indians is funny and well-made no matter how many times you see it. It’s also an example that rooting for the lovable loser in baseball — hello, fans of the Mets, Cubs, Phillies and yes, Indians — is actually endearing.
THE UNDERRATED VETERAN
Description: The movie that’s like Rafael Palmiero — a player you don’t fully appreciate for years, then realize is amazing
Example: Eight Men Out
When people talk about baseball movies, you always hear about Bull Durham or Field Of Dreams. But you don’t hear much about Eight Men Out. Which is a shame. It’s my favorite baseball movie. John Sayles’ telling of the 1919 White Sox — or Black Sox — game-throwing scandal is a masterful drama and a stirring document of baseball history.
THE SCRAPPY UTILITY PLAYER
Description: The movie that’s like David Eckstein — a fun, energetic, taken-for-granted player who makes you smile every now and then
Example: Little Big League
I know. The premise is ridiculous: The owner of the Minnesota Twins dies and leaves the team to his pre-teen grandson, who then names himself the manager. But it’s less ridiculous than the campy Rookie Of The Year. Mainly because this movie seems to have a true love of the game — and more believable game-time sequences. It’s cute, and I like it. Bench me if you don’t agree.
The best baseball movie ever and the second greatest movie ever….Field of Dreams!!!!
I don’t quarrel with your movie choices, but in no way shape or form is Rafael Palmeiro amazing.
I knew it, I knew it. I said I bet he writes about “A League of Their Own” and leaves out “The Lou Gehrig Story”. Brent, you are becoming a real concern for me. You’re writing is excellent but you eye for entertainment is very jaundiced.
All are great!!!…I watched some more Video Scenes of Baseball movies from this site and would like to share with you all guyz…its awesome have a look.
Here’s the link http://www.dailytop10.net/top-10-baseball-movies/